Granny Flat Or Extension—What’s The Difference?

Table of Contents

    Granny flats and home extensions are both popular ways to expand living space, but they serve different purposes and offer distinct advantages. 

    A granny flat, a secondary dwelling, is a self-contained unit separate from the main house, often used for extended family, rental income, or guest accommodation. It usually includes a bedroom, bathroom, and small kitchen. 

    On the other hand, a home extension involves adding more rooms or expanding existing spaces within the primary residence, seamlessly integrating with the main home. While granny flats offer independent living, extensions enhance the existing home structure for increased functionality and space.

    Let’s get straight to the point.

    Granny flats and home extensions both expand living space but serve different purposes. A granny flat is a self-contained unit separate from the main home, often used for elderly relatives, rental income, or guest accommodation. 

    In contrast, a home extension integrates additional rooms into the main structure, offering seamless functionality. Granny flats provide privacy and independent use, while home extensions offer more living space but are costlier and less flexible for rental purposes. 

    Choosing between the two depends on your budget, space, lifestyle needs, and council regulations. Both options can increase property value.

    The Granny Flat

    A granny apartment is a separate dwelling typically on the same property as a main residence. It may be joined to or separated from the main home while maintaining a separate entrance.

    While the name suggests it’s intended for elderly family members, granny flats have many uses beyond housing ageing relatives.

    granny flat11

    Common Uses Of A Granny Flat

    • Housing for elderly relatives: A granny flat allows older family members to live independently but remain close for care and support.
    • Rental income: Many homeowners rent out their granny flats, earning extra income through long-term tenants or short-term rentals like Airbnb.
    • Guest accommodation: A granny flat can provide a comfortable and private space for visiting friends or family.
    • Home office: With remote work becoming more common, a granny flat can offer a quiet and private workspace away from the distractions of the main home.
    • Teenager retreat: It can serve as a semi-independent living space for teenagers or young adults who still live at home but want privacy.

    Pros Of A Granny Flat

    • Independent space: One of the main benefits of a granny flat is its separation. It provides an independent living area close to the main home.
    • Potential for rental income: Building a granny flat can be a smart financial investment, especially if you rent it out to tenants or list it on short-term rental platforms.
    • Flexible use: A granny flat offers versatile uses, whether for family, work, or income.
    • Adds value to the property: A granny flat can increase the value of your property, especially if it’s well-designed and complies with council regulations.

    Cons Of A Granny Flat

    • Space requirements: Building a granny flat requires sufficient land. If you have a small backyard, it might not be feasible.
    • Council regulations: Depending on where you live, obtaining approval for a granny flat can involve navigating strict local council regulations. In some areas, there may be limits on the size or the ability to rent it out.
    • Separate utilities: A granny flat may require its own plumbing, electricity, and other utilities, which can raise the price and complexity of the building.
    • Limited integration with the main home: If you’re looking for additional living space that integrates seamlessly with your day-to-day activities, there may be better options than a granny flat since it’s typically a separate structure.

    The Home Extension

    A home extension is a renovation project that expands the floor space of your existing home. Extensions can range from adding an extra bedroom or bathroom to building a new living area, such as a second storey. 

    Unlike a granny flat, a home extension is integrated into the original structure.

    Types Of Home Extensions

    • Single-storey extensions: These extensions add extra rooms to the ground floor of your home, such as additional bedrooms, living rooms, or a larger kitchen.
    • Double-storey extensions: Adding a second storey is an option if you have limited yard space but need more room. It significantly increases the size of your home without taking up more land.
    • Rear extensions: Extending out the back of your home is common, especially for adding family rooms or expanding kitchens.
    • Garage conversions: Converting a garage into a living area can be a cost-effective way to extend your home without needing new foundations.

    Pros Of A Home Extension

    • More living space: A home extension adds functional living areas that integrate seamlessly with your existing space.
    • There is no need for separate utilities: Since an extension is part of your main home, it uses the same plumbing, electrical, and heating systems, making it easier to manage than a granny flat.
    • Increased property value: A well-executed extension can significantly increase the value of your home, particularly in areas where larger homes are in demand.
    • Customisation: A home extension can be tailored to your needs and preferences, providing more control over the final design and layout.

    Cons Of A Home Extension

    • Cost: Extensions can be expensive, especially when compared to building a granny flat. They often require more extensive structural work and take longer to complete.
    • Disruption: Extending your home can disrupt your daily life. Depending on the project’s scope, you may have to deal with noise, dust, and limited access to parts of your home for weeks or even months.
    • Planning approvals: As with granny flats, a home extension requires approval from the local council, which can be time-consuming and may come with strict requirements.
    • Less flexibility: Unlike a granny flat, a home extension is integrated into your existing space, meaning it can’t easily be used for rental purposes or as a fully independent living unit.

    Granny Flat Or Extension—Which Is The Better Investment?

    Both a granny flat and a home extension can be excellent investments, but the right choice depends on your situation.

    Financial Return

    A granny flat may provide a quicker financial return, especially if you rent it out. The rental income can sometimes cover the construction costs within a few years, making it a profitable investment. 

    Conversely, extensions typically add more value to the main home, especially in family-oriented suburbs where larger homes are in demand.

    Lifestyle Considerations

    granny flat

    If your main goal is to create a separate living area for a family member, or if you plan to rent out the space, a granny flat might be the better option. It offers privacy and independence, making it ideal for accommodating elderly relatives or tenants.

    However, if you need more space for your growing family or want to upgrade your home’s layout, a home extension is likely the better choice. Extensions allow for better integration with your daily life and can improve the overall functionality of your home.

    Flexibility And Future Use

    A granny flat is a flexible investment. It can be used as a rental property, guest house, or even converted into a home office. As family needs change, the space can adapt to different uses. 

    A home extension, while valuable, offers less flexibility regarding independent living spaces or rental opportunities.

    Conclusion

    When deciding between a granny flat or a home extension, consider available space, budget, lifestyle needs, and future investment potential. 

    Granny flats offer flexibility, independence, and potential for rental income, while home extensions provide seamless integration with your existing home and more tailored living spaces. 

    Both options can significantly increase your property’s value, but the right choice depends on your situation. Consult with your local council and seek advice from professional builders to ensure your project complies with all regulations and meets your long-term goals.

    Frequently Asked Questions About Granny Flat

    What Is The Difference Between A Granny Flat And A Townhouse?

    A townhouse is more than two dwellings on the same title, usually strata. A townhouse may be attached or detached. A granny flat is associated with the main dwelling and can be attached or detached.

    What Is Another Name For A Granny Flat?

    Secondary suites are self-contained apartments, cottages, or small residential units situated on a property with a separate main, single-family home, duplex, or other residential unit. Another name for them is auxiliary dwelling units. ADUs, in-law apartments, granny flats, and garden suites.

    What Is Another Name For A One-Bedroom Flat?

    A studio apartment is an apartment with just one room. They are also known as one-room homes.

    Is It Called A Flat Or An Apartment?

    In America, an apartment is more frequently referred to as a group of rooms that may span more than one floor. In Britain, an apartment is a dwelling on a single story.

    What Is The Difference Between A Flat And A Condo?

    Generally, a condominium is a private residence leased to renters; it may be a standalone home or a flat/apartment. However, in common parlance, “condo” exclusively refers to apartments and flats. Since condos are rented and owned by individuals, the rental procedure is more intimate and one-on-one. 

    Posted in
    Google Rating
    5.0
    Based on 41 reviews
    js_loader
    Scroll to Top